The Problem IS Religion

I was five years old, on my knees at my bedside, my hands clasped together on my bed, reciting the ‘Lord’s Prayer’ to my grandmother when I decided there was no god.

“Now I lay me down to sleep.
I pray the Lord my soul to keep.
If I should die before I wake,
I pray the Lord my soul to take.”

I had no idea who I was saying this prayer to beyond my grandmother, and I was sure she wasn’t the Lord. I performed the whole prayer thing at her request when she babysat. My parents never instructed us to pray before bed, or pray at all. It was a scary prayer, reminding me that death was real, and ever-present. Perhaps when my parents came home from their date-night and went to sleep they’d never wake up. Or my sister in the room next door would die before waking…

“Who is the Lord, grandma?” I asked her as I climbed into bed.

“God.”

“Who’s god?”

“Who knows. Go to sleep.”

I didn’t. I lay there in the dark, my usual fear suddenly overshadowed by reason. I’d said the prayer at least 30 times, every time our grandmother babysat, for years by then. No one I loved died. Nothing bad happened. My grandma was simply carrying forward what she thought was a Jewish tradition, (though recently I learned the prayer in The New England Primer was the primary schoolbook used to teach Christian doctrine to colonial kids).

“What’s a soul,” I’d asked my mother several times after grandma babysat.

“No one knows,” she told me offhandedly.

“Do we all have one, or just some of us, or no one does,” I persisted. “And does it die when we do or live forever?”

“Who knows. I don’t really think about it. And you think too much.” And that’s how my mother shut down most of my spiritual or philosophical queries.

“Jews don’t believe in a soul, or Heaven or Hell like Christians do,” my father preached proudly at many dinnertime diatribes to my spiritual questions. “We’re not forgiven for bad behavior upon death if we confess. Jews focus on the living by helping to rid the world of injustice, not for rewards after death.”

My siblings and I were raised L.A. Jewish, i.e. ‘reform,’ meaning going to temple on high holy days (and lunch at Canter’s Deli after the boring sermon), and celebrating Hanukkah and Passover. And that was about it. I don’t know if my mom knew her mother insisted my sister and I perform an evening prayer. They didn’t pray, or I never saw that, and they never said they did.

Our parents raised us Jewish because their parents did them, as did their parents before them, and so on. My father believed ‘Man invented God.’ My mom was…busy, and didn’t care to contemplate if there was One. “Life is what you make it.” And “Turn lemons into lemonade,” were her common refrains. And while neither were true ‘believers’ in the religious dogma, both my parents considered themselves Jewish. ‘Culturally Jewish,’ maybe, but absolutely part of an ancient, exclusive, albeit bullied tribe.

I announced I didn’t believe in any god, or a soul at Passover to my parents, siblings, grandparents, aunt and uncle and their three sons. I was the youngest among them and had to read the four questions, a long-standing tradition to pass on a mystical, extremely violent Jewish legend.

“You don’t know what you believe. You’re five years old,” my father announced to the table, and everyone laughed.

Months later our parents enrolled my sister and me in religious school to ‘learn what it means to be Jewish.’ I vigorously protested, enumerated my reasons why I shouldn’t be forced into a religious identity I didn’t believe in, to no avail. On Saturday mornings our mom drove us over the Hollywood Hills to Wilshire Blvd Temple, the oldest, and still most prestigious temple in L.A., which is precisely why my father insisted we join there. He came only on one of the High Holy Days annually, to cultivate business relationships, and an excuse to eat at Cantor’s.

The more stories I heard in religious school, the less I wanted to be a part of a tribe who believed the universe began with Adam and Eve, and her ‘desires are’ [required to be] ‘for her husband’ who ‘rules over her’ (Genesis 3:16). Impossible to believe being born into the Space Age, and the Women’s Liberation Movement. I grew up believing women are equal to men, though my father, and most of the Jewish guys I dated clearly did not. I didn’t care for the patriarchy I’d witnessed in most Jewish households, including my own, in which the wife overwhelmingly defaulted to the husband.

I was 9 when I declared myself an Atheist and absolutely refused to go to temple anymore. My older sister backed me, and our mother acquiesced on the promise we’d both come back to the temple to get a bat mitzvah. And regardless that the entire performance was a sham for me, I lived up to my promise. Unfortunately, it reinforced my mother’s belief that I was willing to become part of her beloved Tribe.

My spiritual and intellectual separation from my mother’s tribe became the wall between us. Her fervent proclamations I should ‘marry a Jew and raise Jewish children’ colored my ability to trust her interests mirrored mine in finding love over propagating Judaism. She insisted I was a Jew whether I ‘admitted it’ or not, regardless that she never expressed any belief in a god, or the male-dominated Bible stories I whined about on the way home from temple.

More bricks in the wall between my mother and I whenever I dated, or even went out with a non-Jew. “Why are you wasting your time with ‘fill in name of non-jew?’

Perhaps for my mother’s approval, my sister went the other way, dating Jews exclusively, on a mission to marry young and raise Jewish children. I became the Black Sheep of my family, as I had no intention of marrying a Jewish man and indoctrinating my children with what I felt by then was an ancient, and rather misogynist tribe.

I was 18 when my developmentally disabled half-brother, ten years my senior, announced he’d accepted Jesus as his Savior and had converted to Christianity (at the insistence of his god-fearing Born Again fiancé).

My mother’s son, who finally tamed his manic-depression with daily Lithium and became a wealthy Palm Springs realtor; her Jewish son that had spent years rallying donors to build the gorgeous Chabad Temple in the desert had become a fanatical Christian? He’d raise Christian babies. His children would never know they were really Jewish — that they belonged to her Tribe.

Shortly after her son’s wedding, my mother became a Born Again Jew. She lost contact with her son within months, unable to tolerate his preaching quotes from the New Testament to ‘Save her soul,’ whenever they got together.

A few years later my sister married the son of a Holocaust survivor. She became our mother’s beacon, the shiny example I should follow to find a ‘nice Jewish man to marry’ who’ll take care of me, even though in my experience with Jewish households the women took more care of the men than the other way around.

Indeed, my sister had children and raised them Jewish. I was “a monster” as an atheist. Fearing I would infect her children to actually THINK about the beliefs she was indoctrinating them with, she kept my niece and nephews at arms length. I got to see them at holiday dinners in which our parents were present, and that was about it. And while I made sure to send her three kids gifts for birthdays and Hanukkah, they never once thanked me. Clearly, the teachings of Judaism did not include kindness.

Religion tore my family apart. It started with me, discovering the ‘teachings’ in the Old and New Testament were fables, made up by literate men, which were few 5000 yrs ago, elite men with an agenda to control others to preserve their lifestyle and legacy.

My half-brother became estranged and my mother did not know her first born grandchild until he was 7 years old because her son chose to believe in Jesus instead of Moses, or along with Moses, but really, why the fuck should anyone care what any of us believes in spiritually?!

But people do.

If Jews don’t recognize Jesus as the son of god, and Christians do, then who’s right? Both can’t be. Either he is, or he was just a self-proclaimed prophet, one of many at that time.

If Christians or Jews follow their Bibles, and Muslims follow the Quran, which book is the truth?

Bloody wars over who is ‘right’ have plagued humanity from the inception of religion. Even in our ‘enlightened’ modern age, extremists acting in the name of both Islam and Judaism have committed horrific acts of violence over religious ideology in recent decades.

Beyond the wars, the family estrangements, or the physical and emotional walls built in the name of religion, any ‘faith’ that requires [blind] belief in an omniscience and omnipresent being laying down rules to live by that cannot be questioned promotes ignorance. And ignorance makes one easy to manipulate.

The 5 Poorest States in the US:

  1. Mississippi
  2. West Virginia
  3. Louisiana
  4. New Mexico
  5. Arkansas

They are also some of the most religious states in our nation.

As of 2026, approximately 85% of the global population identifies with a religion. Christianity and Islam collectively account for over half of the population on Earth. Only 15% of the planet identifies as secular, atheist, agnostic, or otherwise religiously unaffiliated — THINKERS vs BELIEVERS.

Religious scholars and true believers argue humanity would not have achieve what we have today without the rules from on-high most try to live by. But I call bullshit. Religion did NOT invent morality. Acceptable standards of behavior were defined eons ago since survival depended on cooperation. Ripping someone off, or killing them does not win friends or trading partners even in caveman days. ‘Thou shall not steal’ or ‘Commit murder,’ were already established societal values when they were written as ‘Commandments’ in the Old Testament.

Religion did NOT invent communities. It simply made them exclusionary.

Religious ideologies have thwarted advances in medicine, science, equal rights, and economic equity. Religious leaders sway the will of their flock, and the politicians who make the laws that govern us. Pew Research Center reported that in the 2024 presidential election [approx] 79% of Trump voters identified as Christian.

In ancient Hebrew culture, and even today in the Orthodox Jewish community, physical exploration of the human body is blocked by [spiritual] laws. Christianity adopted these religious limitations, naming it ‘desecration,’ essentially restricting research and delaying advances in medicine and healthcare.

In the New Testament, Jesus instructs his followers to “make disciples of all nations,” (Matthew 28:19). This instruction began the 2000 yr war of conversion known as the Crusades. Christian missionaries spreading His word virtually wiped out the Native American population along the west coast. My half-brother’s insistence on proselytizing Christianity to our parents tore their relationship apart.

In Israel and globally, conservative Zionists and Orthodox Jews believe they have a religious claim to Gaza, Jerusalem, and to the West Bank based on biblical promises, justifying massive Jewish settlements built in these historically Palestinian regions.

Our religious leaders are influencing policy restricting fetal stem cell research that has the potential to replace limbs, and cure disease before it manifests. State Supreme Courts in several Southern states are vying for Christian prayer in public schools. High-ranking clergy are lobbying our overwhelmingly Christian Supreme Court to ban abortion in every state, effectively denying women the right to have control over our own bodies.

There is NO separation of Church and State in the United States of America. Sadly.

Religion has NOT been the solution to ending war, uniting cultures, moving humanity forward in science, medicine, longevity, inequity. Religion has not made humans more moral, nor more equitable, or accepting. It has thwarted our progress from its inception of mythical interpretations of the unknown by leaders making rules that could not, and still cannot be challenged.

Religion IS the problem. The practice designed to control people who want to be told what to believe (spiritually, politically) rather than THINK. Remember, blind faith makes one easy to manipulate. If you’re willing to believe in fables like the ‘virgin birth’ of a married woman,* than you’re a target mark for, well, almost anything I’m selling.

Religion is divisive, often forcing us to take sides, or endure someone trying to convince us the exclusive rightness of their faith.

Religion — blind belief — is, and has been, the single biggest obstacle to humanity’s advancement. So why do so many keep pushing it on their kids?

—

*If you’re thinking the Virgin Birth’s rarity is what makes it believable as a miracle, correlation is not causation. While there is some evidence Jesus existed and was crucified, there’s nothing that corroborates the Gospels magical tales of his birth, and no record of his parentage or family lineage beyond a mention of his brother, James, who was martyred 30ish yrs after Christ’s crucifixion.

Leave a Reply